Bill > A08764

This bill amends the New York judiciary law to establish a specific procedure for replacing a Court of Appeals judge who recuses themselves from a case. Currently, the law requires most judges to provide a written explanation for their recusal, except in cases where the reason might cause embarrassment or involves personal matters. The new provision focuses specifically on Court of Appeals judges, mandating that when such a judge recuses themselves from a judicial proceeding, a replacement judge will be selected from the Appellate Division on a rotating basis, with selection determined by the judge's seniority. This approach aims to create a systematic and transparent method for maintaining judicial continuity when a Court of Appeals judge cannot participate in a case, ensuring that judicial proceedings can continue smoothly without leaving a gap in judicial review. The bill will take effect 30 days after it becomes law, providing a clear timeline for implementation of this new judicial procedure.

Justice

https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/bills/2025/A8764