Bill > HB1913

This bill amends Pennsylvania law to clarify attorneys' rights to discuss potential damage amounts during closing arguments in civil trials. Specifically, the bill allows attorneys to argue specific monetary damages using lump sums or mathematical formulas, both for plaintiffs seeking compensation and defendants suggesting lower award amounts. Before making such arguments, attorneys must disclose their intent to the court and opposing counsel. When these arguments are made in jury trials, judges must instruct jurors that these suggested damage amounts are merely arguments, not evidence, and that the jury alone determines the appropriate damages. The bill preserves defendants' right to argue for no liability and allows economic damages to be discussed without prior notice if supporting evidence has been introduced during the trial. The new provision applies to trials before judges, juries, or other tribunals and will go into effect 60 days after passage, providing more flexibility and transparency in how attorneys can discuss potential monetary compensation during legal proceedings.

Justice

https://www.palegis.us/legislation/bills/2025/hb1913